Current:Home > FinancePanama’s high court declared a mining contract unconstitutional. Here’s what’s happening next -Excel Wealth Summit
Panama’s high court declared a mining contract unconstitutional. Here’s what’s happening next
View
Date:2025-04-15 11:34:28
PANAMA CITY (AP) — In a historic ruling, Panama’s Supreme Court this week declared that legislation granting a Canadian copper mine a 20-year concession was unconstitutional, a decision celebrated by thousands of Panamanians activists who had argued the project would damage a forested coastal area and threaten water supplies.
The mine, which will now close, has been an important economic engine for the country. But it also triggered massive protests that paralyzed the Central American nation for over a month, mobilizing a broad swath of Panamanian society, including Indigenous communities, who said the mine was destroying key ecosystems they depend on.
In the unanimous decision Tuesday, the high court highlighted those environmental and human rights concerns, and ruled the contract violated 25 articles of Panama’s constitution. Those include the right to live in a pollution-free environment, the obligation of the state to protect the health of minors and its commitment to promote the economic and political engagement of Indigenous and rural communities.
WHAT IS THE FALLOUT OF THE COURT’S RULING?
The ruling would lead to the closure of Minera Panama, the local subsidiary of Canada’s First Quantum Minerals and the largest open-pit copper mine in Central America, according to jurists and environmental activists.
The court said the government should no longer recognize the existence of the mine’s concession and Panama’s President Laurentino Cortizo said “the transition process for an orderly and safe closure of the mine will begin.”
Analysts say it appears highly unlikely that Panama’s government and the mining company will pursue a new agreement based on the resounding rejection by Panamanians.
“There are sectors in the country that would like a new contract, but the population itself does not want more open-pit mining, the message was clear,” said Rolando Gordón, dean of the economics faculty at the state-run University of Panama. “What remains now is to reach an agreement to close the mine.”
COULD PANAMA BE THE SUBJECT OF ARBITRATION?
Analysts say the mining company is free to pursue international arbitration to seek compensation for the closure based on commercial treaties signed between Panama and Canada. Before the ruling, the company said it had the right to take steps to protect its investment.
With the ruling, the Panamanian government and the mining company are headed for arbitration at the World Bank’s international center for arbitration of investment disputes, in Washington, said Rodrigo Noriega, a Panamanian jurist.
Marta Cornejo, one of the plaintiffs, said “we are not afraid of any arbitration claim” and that they are “capable of proving that the corrupt tried to sell our nation and that a transnational company went ahead, knowing that it violated all constitutional norms.”
In a statement after the verdict, the mining company said it had “operated consistently with transparency and strict adherence to Panamanian legislation.” It emphasized that the contract was the result of “a long and transparent negotiation process, with the objective of promoting mutual economic benefits, guaranteeing the protection of the environment.”
WHAT WILL HAPPEN WITH THE THOUSANDS OF JOBS CREATED BY THE MINE?
Cortizo, who had defended the contract arguing it would keep 9,387 direct jobs, more than what the mine reports, said that the closing of the mine must take place in a “responsible and participative” manner due to the impact it would have.
The company has said the mine generates 40,000 jobs, including 7,000 direct jobs, and that it contributes the equivalent of 5% of Panama’s GDP.
The court verdict and the eventual closure of the mine prompted more protests, this time by mine workers.
“We will not allow our jobs, which are the livelihood of our families, to be put at risk,” the Union of Panamanian Mining Workers said in a statement.
WHAT WILL BE THE ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF THE EVENTUAL MINE CLOSURE?
Panama two weeks ago received a first payment of $567 million from First Quantum, as stipulated in their contract. Due to the legal dispute, the amount went directly to a restricted account.
The contract also stipulated that Panama would receive at least $375 million annually from the mining company, an amount that critics considered meager.
Minera Panama published a scathing statement on Wednesday saying the Supreme Court decision will likely have a negative economic impact and warned that lack of maintenance of drainage systems in the mines could have “catastrophic consequences.” The move, the company said, “puts at risk” all of Panama’s other business contracts.
What seems to be clear is that the closure will negatively impact the country’s public coffers, said Gordón of University of Panama.
The government “had hoped that with that contract it would plug some holes in the nation’s budget, which it will not be able to do now,” Gordón said. “The situation of public finances is still reeling from five weeks of semi-paralysis in the country due to the protests.”
____
Follow AP’s coverage of Latin America and the Caribbean at https://apnews.com/hub/latin-america
veryGood! (8)
Related
- 'We're reborn!' Gazans express joy at returning home to north
- A Wisconsin caretaker claims her friend was drinking an unusual cocktail before her death. Was she poisoned?
- Colorado organizers fail to gather enough signatures to put anti-abortion measure on the ballot
- Tesla recalls Cybertrucks due to faulty accelerator pedal that can get stuck
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- How Blacksburg Books inspires its Virginia community to shop local
- What is cloud seeding and did it play any role in the Dubai floods?
- Hawaii lawmakers take aim at vacation rentals after Lahaina wildfire amplifies Maui housing crisis
- Google unveils a quantum chip. Could it help unlock the universe's deepest secrets?
- Mandisa, Grammy-winning singer and American Idol alum, dead at 47
Ranking
- 'Most Whopper
- Starbucks is rolling out new plastic cups this month. Here's why.
- California is rolling out free preschool. That hasn’t solved challenges around child care
- Former resident of New Hampshire youth center describes difficult aftermath of abuse
- What to watch: O Jolie night
- Theater Review: ‘Stereophonic’ is a brilliant ‘Behind the Music’ play on Broadway
- Boston Dynamics' robot Atlas being billed as 'fully-electric humanoid': Watch it in action
- Maryland student arrested over school shooting plot after 129-page manifesto was found
Recommendation
Biden administration makes final diplomatic push for stability across a turbulent Mideast
UFL schedule for Week 4 games: D.C. Defenders vs. Birmingham Stallions in big matchup
Save an Extra 25% on Abercrombie & Fitch’s Chic & Stylish Activewear, with Tees & Tanks as Low as $25
How an Arizona Medical Anthropologist Uses Oral Histories to Add Depth to Environmental Science
Scoot flight from Singapore to Wuhan turns back after 'technical issue' detected
Mandisa, Grammy-winning singer and American Idol alum, dead at 47
Tori Spelling Shares She Once Peed in Her Son's Diaper While Stuck in Traffic
Is pickle juice good for you? Here's what experts want you to know